Pre-order Menu
Pre-Order NowYear-round Pies
These pies are available by pre-order year round.
Because Miss American Pies are made with Love specifically for each customer, all special orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.
-
The Signature Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with the perfect combination of apples, peaches, and blueberries, topped with an oatmeal crumb and a beautiful lattice crust.
-
Classic Apple Pie
A double portion of our flaky all-butter crust filled with lusciously seasoned apples. A classic memory food. Sugar-free option also available.
-
Apple Crumb
Choose from our flaky, all-butter crust, or our dairy-free or gluten-free, crisp cookie crust, filled with our classic apple filling and topped with a flavorful oat crumb.
-
Cherry Crumb
Choose from our flaky, all-butter crust, or our dairy-free or gluten-free, crisp cookie crust, filled with tart Montmorency cherries, a hint of almond, and topped with a flavorful oat crumb.
-
Turtle Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust layered with pecans, caramel, and chocolate, then topped with a caramel drizzle or chopped pecans. Basically a candy bar with a crust.
-
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
A subtly chocolate version of our flaky, all-butter crust layered with sweetened peanut butter and a creamy marbled chocolate ganache.
-
Coconut Cream Pie
Our handmade coconut and oat granola crust layered with handmade coconut pudding and sweet whipped cream, topped with lightly toasted coconut.
-
Old-Fashioned Banana Cream Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust layered with handmade vanilla pudding, ripe banana, and sweet whipped cream.
-
Salted-Caramel Banana Cream Pie
A nutty pistachio and almond crumb crust layered with rum-infused banana pudding and ripe bananas, smeared with slightly sweetened whipped coconut cream, and topped with a sprinkling of salted caramel fudge.
gluten free, vegan
Spring & Summer Pies
These pies are available by pre-order seasonally.
Because Miss American Pies are made with Love specifically for each customer, all special orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.
-
Black and Blueberry Crisp
A delectably textured, all-butter cornmeal crust, filled with homemade black and blueberry jam, combined with fresh, whole, blackberries and blueberries. Topped with a sweet coconut and oatmeal crumb.
-
Apple Raspberry Crisp
Choose from our dairy-free or gluten-free, crisp cookie crust, filled with a seasonal raspberries and apples, and topped with a crunchy oat crumb.
Also available with a standard all-butter crust and a pastry top.
-
Peach Cobbler
Fresh, juicy peaches and a perfect combination of spices, topped with our crunchy, sweet biscuit crust. A southern favorite.
-
Peach Pie
A double portion of our flaky, all-butter crust filled with fresh peaches and a perfect combination of spices. A southern favorite. Vegan and gluten-free crumb option also available.
-
Raspberry Peach Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with fresh, summer peaches and raspberries, and topped with a beautiful lattice. Also available as vegan or gluten free crumble.
-
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with a perfect combination of fresh, delicious rhubarb and strawberries, a hint of orange, and topped with a beautiful lattice. Also available as a vegan or gluten-free crumble.
-
Key Lime Pie
Our handmade graham cracker crust filled with tart key lime custard and topped with sweet whipped cream.
-
Chocolate Covered Strawberry Pie
A nutty pistachio and almond crumb crust filled with strawberry-infused dark chocolate custard and topped with fresh, ripe strawberries.
-
French Silk Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with a light, fluffy, dark chocolate mousse and topped with sweet whipped cream.
-
Lemon Chiffon Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust layered with fluffy lemon cream and topped with semi-sweet chocolate drizzle.
Fall Pies
These pies are available by pre-order seasonally.
Because Miss American Pies are made with Love specifically for each customer, all special orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.
-
Caramel Apple Pie
A double portion of our flaky, all-butter crust filled with lusciously seasoned apples soaked in creamy caramel.
-
Cranberry Apple Crisp
Choose from our flaky, all-butter crust, or a dairy-free or gluten-free version of our crisp cookie crust filled with a delectable combination of cranberries and apples, seasoned with orange and nutmeg and topped with a flavorful oatmeal crumb.
-
Dutch Apple Walnut
Our gluten-free crisp cookie crust filled with beautifully-seasoned creamed apples, and topped with a flavorful walnut streusel.
-
Bacon Lattice Apple Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with lusciously seasoned apples and topped with a crispy bacon lattice! Available for special order on Father’s Day only. Also available in gluten-free crust.
-
Pumpkin Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with a perfectly seasoned and not-too-sweet pumpkin custard. For holiday orders, we top it with seasonal cutouts and candied cranberries.
-
Vegan Pumpkin Pie
A dairy-free version of our crisp cookie crust filled with a spicy pumpkin custard, then topped with freshly whipped coconut cream.
-
Sweet Potato Pie
Choose from our flaky, all-butter crust, or our gluten-free butter cookie crust, filled with a creamy sweet potato custard. Add fresh whipped cream (optional) to finish it off.
-
Chocolate Pumpkin Chess Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust, filled with rich, chocolatey pumpkin custard and topped with pumpkin spice whipped cream
$50.00
-
Classic Pecan Pie
Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with a classic combination of eggs, butter and sugar, and topped with toasted pecans. Another southern favorite. Also available in gluten-free option.
-
Double Chocolate Maple Pecan Pie
Our chocolate all-butter crust with a rich sticky filling featuring semisweet chocolate, real maple syrup, Cacao Maple Vodka, and packed to the brim with crunchy pecans. A chocoholic’s dream.
Winter Pies
These pies are available by pre-order seasonally.
Because Miss American Pies are made with Love specifically for each customer, all special orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.
-
Pear and Lavender Crisp
Our dairy-free crisp cookie crust, filled with sweet red pears flavored with a hint of lavender and topped with a flavorful oatmeal crumb.
Also available in a gluten-free or standard crust.
-
Dark Chocolate Coconut Cream
A chocolate version of our dairy-free crust filled with rich, dark chocolate pudding and smeared with slightly sweetened whipped coconut cream, topped with lightly toasted coconut and freeze-dried cherries.
-
Peppermint Mocha Cream Pie
A cocoa mint cookie crust filled with espresso infused mocha pudding and topped with fresh peppermint whipped cream. A perfect holiday treat.
-
Chocolate Cherry Chiffon
Our flaky, all-butter crust, layered with thick chocolate ganache, light, fluffy cherry cream and house-made tart cherry jam.
-
Cranberry Orange Tart
A sweet and spicy gingerbread all-butter crust, filled with a perfectly smooth, creamy, and tangy cranberry orange curd, topped with fresh, beautifully sugared cranberries and orange zest. A holiday jewel. Also available in gluten-free crust.
Savory Pies
These pies are available for pre-order any time of year.
Because Miss American Pies are made with Love specifically for each customer, all special orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.
-
Chicken Pot Pie
A creamy, cognac-infused base with shredded chicken, onions, potatoes, peas, and carrots then topped with our flaky, all-butter crust and the perfect combination of herbs. Serves 8-10 people.
-
Chili Pot Pie
This family recipe starts with lean ground beef and is mixed with tomatoes, kidney beans, onions, and flavorful seasonings and topped with sweet, made-from-scratch cornbread. Serves 8-10.
-
Quiche
Our creamy, crustless egg dish, available in spinach and cheddar or bacon and cheddar. Serves 8-10.
-
Southern Tomato Pie- 9"
Our flaky, all-butter crust, with layers of sharp cheddar, roasted tomatoes, and basil, then topped with a lattice crust. (serves 4-6)
$45.00
Breads and Cookies
These items are available for pre-order by the dozen and half dozen.
Because Miss American Pies are made with Love specifically for each customer, all special orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.
-
Cheddar Biscuits
Fluffy cream biscuits, flavored with sharp cheddar cheese and black pepper. Available with or without bacon.
-
Apple Cinnamon Monkey Bread
Also known as “break-away bread,” this yummy breakfast dessert consists of small pieces of cinnamon roll dough, stuck together with a cinnamon-sugar glaze and filled with apple cinnamon pie filling.
-
Mini Loaves
Like a muffin, but sharable. available flavors:
Mom's Banana Bread
Blueberry Crunch Bread
Almond Poppyseed Bread
Chocolate Chip Pumpkin Bread
Cinnamon Streusel Coffee Cake with Espresso Glaze
Apple Cinnamon Monkey Bread
-
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside.... your Grandma's quintessential chocolate chip cookie.
-
Monster Cookies
Oats, peanut butter, chocolate chips, M&Ms. Gluten Free.
-
Brownie Crinkle Cookies
A cross between a brownie and a cookie. Crunchy on the outside, rich, soft and fudgy on the inside.
-
Coconut Macaroons
Crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, these sweet treats are a perfect snack.
-
Ginger Snaps
Ginger forward cookies with a snap. Great for dunking or enjoying alone. Available seasonally.
-
Cocoa Mint Cookies
Chocolate Cocoa and peppermint cookies, dipped in white chocolate and sprinkled with peppermint. Available seasonally.