Year-Round Pies

Year-round Pies

These pies are available by pre-order year round.

Because Miss American Pies are made with Love specifically for each customer, all special orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.

The Signature Pie

Our flaky, all-butter crust filled with the perfect combination of apples, peaches, and blueberries, topped with an oatmeal crumb and a beautiful lattice crust.
Classic Apple Pie

A double portion of our flaky all-butter crust filled with lusciously seasoned apples. A classic memory food. Sugar-free option also available.
Apple Crumb

Choose from our flaky, all-butter crust, or our dairy-free or gluten-free, crisp cookie crust, filled with our classic apple filling and topped with a flavorful oat crumb.
Cherry Crumb

Choose from our flaky, all-butter crust, or our dairy-free or gluten-free, crisp cookie crust, filled with tart Montmorency cherries, a hint of almond, and topped with a flavorful oat crumb.

Turtle Pie

Our flaky, all-butter crust layered with pecans, caramel, and chocolate, then topped with a caramel drizzle or chopped pecans. Basically a candy bar with a crust.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

A subtly chocolate version of our flaky, all-butter crust layered with sweetened peanut butter and a creamy marbled chocolate ganache.

Coconut Cream Pie

Our handmade coconut and oat granola crust layered with handmade coconut pudding and sweet whipped cream, topped with lightly toasted coconut.
Old-Fashioned Banana Cream Pie

Pie our flaky, all-butter crust layered with handmade vanilla pudding, ripe banana, and sweet whipped cream.
Salted-Caramel Banana Cream Pie

A nutty pistachio and almond crumb crust layered with rum-infused banana pudding and ripe bananas, smeared with slightly sweetened whipped coconut cream, and topped with a sprinkling of salted caramel fudge.

gluten free, vegan