IMG_6840.JPG

Menu

~Every Day Pies~

These pies are available any time of year

 

Stop in to our new location for a slice or to pick up a whole pie. (call ahead for availability) We also carry cookies, breakfast pastries, savory items, and coffee for your morning commute or for a snack to get you through the day. visit us at 86 5th ave, Brooklyn, 11217

Signature pie- our flaky, all-butter crust, filled with the perfect combination of apples, peaches, and blueberries, topped with a crunchy, oatmeal crumb and a beautiful lattice crust

Classic Apple Pie- a double portion of our flaky all-butter crust, filled with lusciously seasoned apples...a classic memory food.

Cherry lattice- our flaky all-butter crust, filled with tart montmorency cherries, a hint of almond, and topped with a beautiful lattice.

Turtle Pie- our flaky, all butter crust, layered with pecans, caramel, and chocolate, then topped with a caramel drizzle.  Basically a candy bar with a crust

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie- a subtly chocolate version of our flaky, all-butter crust, layered with sweetened peanut butter and a creamy marbled chocolate ganache 

coconut cream pie- our hand made, oatmeal and coconut crumb crust , layered with handmade coconut pudding and sweet whipped cream, topped with lightly toasted coconut

old fashioned banana cream pie- flaky, all butter crust, layered with handmade vanilla pudding, ripe banana, and sweet whipped cream

White Chocolate banana cream pie- a subtly chocolate version of our flaky, all-butter crust, layered with handmade white chocolate pudding, ripe banana, and sweet whipped cream, then topped with semi-sweet chocolate drizzle.

Apple Crumb (vegan)- a dairy-free version of our classic crust, filled with our classic apple filling and topped with a  flavorful streusel

Cherry Crumb (vegan)- a dairy-free version of our classic crust, filled with tart montmorency cherries, a hint of almond, and topped with a flavorful streusel

Salted Caramel Banana Cream Pie (vegan, gluten free)- a nutty pistachio and almond crumb crust, layered with rum infused banana pudding and ripe bananas, smeared with slightly sweetened, whipped coconut cream, and topped with a sprinkling of salted caramel.


Fall ~ Winter

   Spring ~ Summer        

These pies are available seasonally

french silk pie- our flaky, all-butter crust, filled with a light, fluffy, dark chocolate mousse and topped with sweet whipped cream

Lemon Chiffon pie- our flaky, all butter crust, layered with fluffy lemon cream and semi-sweet chocolate drizzle.

dutch apple pie-  our flaky all-butter crust, filled with beautifully seasoned creamed apples, and topped with a flavorful streusel

black and blueberry crisp-  a delectably textured, all-butter, cornmeal crust, filled homemade black and blueberry jam, combined with fresh, whole, blackberries and blueberries. Topped with a sweet coconut oil and oatmeal crumble

peach pie- a double portion of our flaky all-butter crust, filled with fresh peaches and a perfect combination of spices...A southern favorite. 

rhubarb pie- a double portion of our flaky all-butter crust, filled with fresh, delicious rhubarb, sweetened to perfection.  once you try it, you'll be addicted!

strawberry rhubarb pie- our flaky all-butter crust, filled with a perfect combination of fresh, delicious rhubarb, and strawberries, a hint of orange, and topped with a beautiful lattice.

raspberry peach pie- our flaky all-butter crust, filled with fresh, summer peaches and raspberries, and topped with a beautiful lattice.

Key Lime pie- our handmade graham cracker crust, filled with tart key lime custard and topped with sweet whipped cream

Chocolate Covered Strawberry pie (vegan, gluten free)- a nutty pistachio and almond crumb crust, filled with strawberry infused dark chocolate custard and topped with fresh, ripe strawberries.

Caramel Apple Pie- a double portion of our flaky all-butter crust, filled with lusciously seasoned apples, and soaked in creamy caramel 

Cranberry Apple Crisp (vegan)- a dairy-free version of our classic crust, filled with a delectable combination of cranberries and apples, seasoned with orange and nutmeg, and topped with a vegan oatmeal crumb

pumpkin pie- our flaky, all-butter crust, filled with a perfectly seasoned and not too sweet pumpkin custard, then topped with seasonal cutouts and candied cranberries

pecan pie- our flaky, all-butter crust, filled with a classic combination of eggs, butter and sugar, and topped with toasted pecans...another southern favorite.

double chocolate maple pecan pie- our chocolate, all-butter crust, and a rich sticky filling, featuring semisweet chocolate, real maple syrup, Cacao Maple Vodka, and packed to the brim with crunchy pecans…a chocoholic’s dream.

Bacon apple pie- our flaky, all-butter crust, filled with lusciously seasoned apples, and topped with a crispy bacon lattice! Available for special order on FAther’s Day and Thanksgiving

Pear and Lavender crisp (vegan)- a dairy-free version of our classic crust, filled with sweet red pears, flavored with a hint of lavender, and topped with a vegan oatmeal crumb

Vegan pumpkin pie- a dairy-free version of our classic crust, filled with a perfectly seasoned, vegan, pumpkin custard, then topped with seasonal cutout and candied cranberries

dark Chocolate Coconut cream pie (vegan)- a chocolate version of our dairy-free crust, filled with rich, dark chocolate pudding, smeared with slightly sweetened, whipped coconut cream, and topped with lightly toasted coconut and freeze dried cherries.

Cranberry Orange Tart- a sweet and spicy gingerbread, all-butter crust, filled with a perfectly smooth, creamy, and tangy cranberry orange curd, and topped with fresh, beautifully sugared cranberries and orange zest…a holiday jewel.

 

Because Miss American Pies are made with Love specifically for each customer, all special orders must be placed 24 hours in advance.

Most fruit pies can be made vegan or gluten free. If you have dietary restrictions, please reach out and we will do our best to accommodate.

Miss American Pie also does catering for special events and weddings.  Contact us for pricing and options. 718-789-3747

 
signature

"This is the best thing to happen to Brooklyn since they built the Brooklyn Bridge!..."